For art student Abby (Shiri Appleby), campus life is perfectly swell, including her boyfriend Sy. He's been Abby's dream guy forever, but she's about to get a wake-up call - Quinn (Nick Zano), a fun-loving charmer who knows nothing about art until Abby reluctantly tutors him. And as his winsome personality starts winning her over, she finds herself in the middle of a love triangle. Who will she choose? Her oh-so-perfect - but imaginary boyfriend or this flesh-and-blood reality?